England & Wales Is Taking Its Own Path. The Product-Liability Questions Are Converging.
England & Wales is reconsidering product liability for the digital age. The legal route differs from the EU PLD, but evidence, software and lifecycle control are creating increasingly familiar questions.
A major Law Commission consultation is reopening product liability for the digital age. The legal route differs from the EU PLD, but many of the problems driving reform are increasingly familiar.
In July, I wrote about what the revised EU Product Liability Directive could mean for businesses in Great Britain that remain commercially connected to the European market.
Three months later, the Law Commission review of product liability in England & Wales, under way since December 2025, has reached a much more consequential stage: provisional proposals are now on the table.
The consultation opened on 8 October and runs until 14 January 2027. It addresses software, AI systems, digital supply, online platforms, complex supply chains, evidential difficulty, psychiatric harm, destruction or corruption of data, substantial modification and long-tail exposure.
This is not England & Wales adopting Directive (EU) 2024/2853. The legal solutions are, in several important places, deliberately different.
What is increasingly difficult to ignore is that the reform processes are confronting many of the same modern product problems. For manufacturers, that creates a question larger than either piece of legislation:
Can the organisation explain the product, its changes, its evidence and its decisions whichever liability regime eventually asks the question?
The July argument has moved on
My July article, “UK and the EU Product Liability Directive,” argued that Great Britain being outside the revised EU PLD did not isolate British businesses from the changing evidence and governance environment surrounding products sold into Europe.
That article focused heavily on EU-facing trade, evidence systems, software governance, contracts and product history.
One line remains particularly relevant:
A contract can allocate risk. It cannot create evidence that was never captured.
What is new is not the existence of the Law Commission review. Its terms of reference were published on 8 December 2025.
What is new is that we can now see what the Commission provisionally proposes to do.
That allows a more useful comparison than was possible in July: not whether England & Wales is following Europe, but how two legal systems are responding to products that have become digital, connected, updateable and technically harder to reconstruct.
Similar pressures. Different legal choices.
The Law Commission’s proposals are substantial.
They include a broader product definition covering software and AI systems, digital forms of supply, additional potentially liable actors, clarification of liability following substantial modification, a more structured defect test, new evidential mechanisms, psychiatric harm, mixed-use property, destruction and corruption of data, updated defences, and changes to the long-stop regime.
There are obvious points of comparison with Directive (EU) 2024/2853.
But some of the differences are just as important.
The EU Directive expressly brings certain related services into its product-liability architecture. The Law Commission is not simply reproducing that model.
The Law Commission also proposes treating certain design features of social-media and other online platforms as products in their own right — a materially different route from the EU PLD’s treatment of online platforms as potentially liable economic actors in defined circumstances.
Its proposed risk-sharing mechanism for exceptional evidential difficulty also has no direct EU counterpart.
Those differences matter because they demonstrate the point more convincingly than repeated disclaimers ever could: the legal paths are separate even where some of the underlying product problems are shared.
1. Digital product identity is getting harder to freeze
The Law Commission proposes a future-proof product definition covering software and AI systems whether embedded in physical goods, downloaded or accessed remotely.
Its public materials also identify design components and features of social-media and other online platforms as potential products.
The revised EU PLD separately defines software as a product, while recital 13 explains that this includes AI systems.
The important governance consequence is not that the two definitions are identical. They are not.
It is that product identity increasingly survives beyond the hardware originally shipped.
Software can change behaviour remotely. AI-enabled capability can evolve. Configuration can alter how a system performs, and products may depend on external digital functionality long after initial supply.
For organisations trying to preserve a defensible product history, the product account may therefore need to include far more than design drawings and manufacturing records. Software state, configuration, update history, external dependencies and post-supply decisions can all become part of the factual story.
That is a lifecycle problem before it becomes a courtroom problem.
2. Supply chains are creating new liability questions
The Commission proposes new potentially liable actors to reflect modern routes to market, including fulfilment service providers, UK authorised representatives and, in defined circumstances, what it describes as core participants, which can include online marketplaces.
The revised EU PLD reaches modern supply chains differently through Article 8, which identifies a wider group of economic operators and contains specific rules for online platforms.
The structures are not interchangeable, but the operational question remains durable:
Who controlled what, when, and what evidence demonstrates it?
That matters when hardware, software, logistics, digital services and customer access may be controlled by different companies.
Contracts remain essential. They allocate rights, obligations and financial consequences between organisations.
They cannot recreate product evidence that was never captured.
3. Evidence that cannot be produced is ceasing to be neutral
This is where the comparison becomes particularly interesting.
The Law Commission identifies significant evidential hurdles in technically complex product-liability cases. Its provisional proposals include both a rebuttable presumption of defect and a risk-sharing mechanism for cases involving exceptional evidential difficulties.
The detailed proposal goes beyond a general statement that claimants need help.
The consultation summary sets out a two-tier architecture: specific factual presumptions where information asymmetry favours the defendant, and a separate mechanism for exceptional evidential difficulty under which, once defined thresholds are met, a defendant may choose either to rebut the alleged defect or accept the defect for the purposes of a risk-sharing outcome.
Under that second mechanism, damages would begin from a 50% position and could then be adjusted.
The EU PLD takes a different route.
Article 9 allows courts, on request and subject to defined conditions, to order disclosure of relevant evidence.
Article 10 then establishes rebuttable presumptions. A failure to disclose relevant evidence as required under Article 9(1) triggers a presumption of defectiveness, while Article 10(4) addresses situations in which technical or scientific complexity makes proving defectiveness or causation excessively difficult.
There is no EU risk-sharing outcome equivalent to the Law Commission’s proposal.
That difference is important, but so is the common consequence.
Evidence a producer cannot produce increasingly stops being neutral.
Under the EU Directive, an evidential failure can contribute directly to a statutory presumption. Under the Law Commission’s proposal, exceptional evidential difficulty may alter how the risk of uncertainty is allocated between claimant and defendant.
For product governance, the message is difficult to ignore. What changed, which product state was relevant, what evidence supported the decision and what the organisation knew at the time are becoming more consequential questions.
Those questions belong to product governance long before they become litigation questions.
Legacy edition
This earlier edition is preserved in the archive. The full original publication is available externally where a verified edition link exists.
Read the full original edition on LinkedIn ↗