The Factory That Became a Manufacturer
An engineering retrofit can turn a factory operator into a machinery manufacturer. What Article 18 means for plant modifications, integrators and conformity.
When an engineering change becomes a manufacturing decision under Europe's new Machinery Regulation.
The capital request is ready for approval.
An existing packaging line needs a replacement safety controller. The integrator will also install new protective devices and modify the software coordinating several machine movements. The proposal identifies the cost, engineering resources, installation window and planned return to production.
There is a field for budget approval and another identifying the contractor. Engineering will sign off the tests before production resumes.
But where is the field identifying who has determined whether the modification creates manufacturer obligations?
From 20 January 2027, Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 provides an explicit EU-level framework for that decision. A company modifying machinery it already operates can, in defined circumstances, become the manufacturer of the modified equipment for regulatory purposes.
For factory management, the challenge is recognising when an ordinary engineering-change approval must also become a conformity decision.
The packaging-line example is hypothetical and illustrates alternative technical outcomes.
One project, two decisions
Factories modify machinery for legitimate operational reasons. Components become obsolete, production capacity changes, protective systems are upgraded and new automation is integrated into established lines.
These projects usually pass through several approval processes. Engineering approves the technical solution, procurement agrees the commercial scope, EHS evaluates the hazards and maintenance prepares to inherit the modified installation. Commissioning then establishes whether the equipment performs as intended.
But successful commissioning does not necessarily establish whether the work constitutes a substantial modification under machinery legislation.
Article 18 of Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 states that the person carrying out a substantial modification is considered a manufacturer and becomes subject to the manufacturer obligations in Article 10.
The Regulation exempts a non-professional user making such a modification for personal use. A professional factory operator cannot rely on that exemption merely because the machinery remains within its own premises.
This creates two decisions that should be connected but must not be confused: whether the engineering change is technically acceptable, and whether it creates new manufacturer responsibilities.
The statutory threshold
Article 3(16) does not classify every retrofit, repair or software update as a substantial modification.
The definition concerns a physical or digital change made after machinery or a related product has been placed on the market or put into service, where the change was not foreseen or planned by the manufacturer.
It must create a new hazard or increase an existing risk and require one of two specified protective responses.
The first involves additional guards or protective devices whose processing requires modification of the existing safety control system. The second involves additional protective measures needed to ensure stability or mechanical strength.
All relevant conditions must be assessed.
Consider two versions of the packaging-line upgrade.
In the first, the obsolete controller is replaced with a suitably specified equivalent. The safety functions and required performance levels or safety integrity levels are preserved, the new configuration is validated, and the assessment identifies no new hazard or increased risk engaging the statutory protective-measure conditions.
On those assumed facts, the replacement does not meet the Article 3(16) threshold.
In the second version, the project extends the machine's operating envelope and changes its movements. New access-related hazards are identified, requiring additional protective devices integrated through changes to the safety control system.
If the original manufacturer had not foreseen or planned the modification, these facts strongly indicate a substantial modification under Article 3(16).
That distinction cannot be established by calling the work an automation improvement or a safety upgrade.
It requires examining the actual technical changes, the original manufacturer's documentation, the risk assessment and the resulting protective measures.
Recital 26 also makes clear that maintenance, and repair operations that do not affect compliance with the relevant essential health and safety requirements, should not be regarded as substantial modifications.
A factory need not reassess its legal responsibilities every time it services a machine. It needs a reliable mechanism for identifying modifications that cross the defined threshold.
The manufacturer nobody planned for
If the change meets that threshold, Article 18 brings the applicable Article 10 manufacturer obligations into play.
The responsible person must address the relevant essential health and safety requirements, technical documentation, conformity assessment, EU declaration of conformity, CE marking and accompanying instructions or information.
Article 18 also requires the responsible person to ensure and declare conformity on its sole responsibility and apply the appropriate Article 25 conformity-assessment procedure.
These activities have a cost in engineering work, documentation, specialist review and project coordination. Their omission from the initial scope can create delays even where no notified body is required.
That distinction is particularly important for our hypothetical packaging line.
A typical packaging line is not an Annex I machinery category. Where the modified machinery falls outside Annex I, Article 25(4) requires the manufacturer to use internal production control, Module A.
That procedure does not require a notified body, but it remains a manufacturer conformity-assessment procedure with associated technical and documentary obligations.
The situation differs for machinery and related products included in Annex I.
Part A includes specified categories involving safety components and machinery with fully or partially self-evolving behaviour using machine-learning approaches to ensure safety functions. The prescribed conformity procedures involve a notified body.
Part B includes certain presses and moulding machinery with manual loading, as well as specified protective devices designed to detect persons and logic units ensuring safety functions.
For Part B, Article 25(3) permits internal production control only where the prescribed conditions are satisfied using harmonised standards or common specifications specific to that category and covering all relevant essential health and safety requirements. Otherwise, one of the prescribed third-party procedures must be followed.
Installing an already CE-marked safety controller or protective device does not, by itself, place the entire packaging line within Annex I.
However, developing a qualifying safety component or modifying machinery within an Annex I category may create a different conformity-assessment requirement.
A factory's procurement team therefore needs to know what is being modified, which product category is involved and which procedure applies before assuming that ordinary commissioning will complete the project.
The contract cannot rewrite Article 18
A machinery modification can involve three distinct organisations: the original equipment manufacturer, the factory operating the machinery and a specialist systems integrator.
The factory may define the required production performance, approve the investment and retain responsibility for operating the installation. The integrator may design the changes, develop safety software, install new components and validate the modified system.
Article 18 attaches manufacturer obligations to the person carrying out the substantial modification.
The difficult case is where the operator specifies the safety concept and retains design authority, while the integrator writes the software, installs the equipment and performs the validation.
The Regulation does not establish a simple formula for allocating the manufacturer role between parties in every such arrangement.
The actual work, responsibilities and control over the modification must be assessed. A contract can allocate engineering tasks, deliverables, warranties and indemnities, but cannot override the statutory identification of the responsible person.
This is why the contractual scope should identify more than equipment supply and installation.
It should specify responsibility for the risk assessment, safety-function validation, updated technical documentation, software configuration, conformity assessment and declaration, where applicable.
There is a further point with direct operational consequences.
Under Article 10(3), the manufacturer must retain the required technical documentation and EU declaration of conformity for at least ten years. Where relevant, source code or programming logic must also be made available to competent national authorities following a reasoned request when necessary to check compliance.
If the operator assumes manufacturer obligations while an integrator retains exclusive control of the relevant safety software, the operator needs arrangements that enable it to comply with that obligation.
This does not automatically require unrestricted ownership or transfer of all the integrator's intellectual property. It does require a legally and technically workable route to the information necessary for the regulatory purpose.
The same attention is needed where a substantial modification affects an assembly of machinery. Article 18 allows the documented risk assessment to identify the particular machinery or related products affected, rather than assuming that every part of the assembly is subject to the new conformity obligations.
For integrated production lines, establishing those boundaries can be as important as identifying the responsible organisation.
The January boundary
Regulation 2023/1230 applies from 20 January 2027.
Article 52(1) protects the continued making available of machinery placed on the market in conformity with the previous Machinery Directive before the new Regulation's application date.
Existing machinery does not automatically require a new conformity assessment simply because the calendar reaches 20 January.
Similarly, restarting a production line following ordinary maintenance or a repair that does not affect compliance is not, by itself, a substantial modification.
The relevant issue arises when existing machinery undergoes a qualifying modification.
Recital 26 contemplates a new conformity assessment before substantially modified machinery is placed on the market or put into service. The Regulation does not, however, contain a detailed transitional rule specifically allocating projects whose modification work spans the January boundary.
A project begun in December 2026 and completed after 20 January 2027 should not assume that its original purchase-order date preserves the former regulatory treatment.
The parties need to determine which law applies to the actual modification and when the necessary conformity obligations must be satisfied.
For projects close to the transition date, that determination belongs in the engineering and procurement planning process, before installation and commissioning commitments become difficult to change.
The software in the machine
The new Regulation also establishes requirements for protecting safety-relevant machinery hardware, software and data.
Annex III section 1.1.9 addresses protection against corruption, including evidence of interventions and changes to relevant software or configurations.
It also requires machinery to identify software necessary for safe operation and make that information available in an easily accessible form.
The European Commission's endorsed guidance explains that this information can be provided through a machinery display or an exportable file. It must be obtainable without disproportionate effort and should not depend on complex engineering procedures.
For a factory assuming manufacturer obligations, this creates a practical verification question: can the modified machinery identify the software necessary for its safe operation, including the relevant version or revision?
The answer should be established through the conformity assessment rather than assumed from an integrator's commissioning report.
Annex III section 1.2.1(f) requires the specified tracing log of intervention data and safety-software versions uploaded after placement on the market or putting into service to be enabled for five years after the relevant upload, exclusively to demonstrate conformity following a reasoned request from a competent national authority.
The Commission's endorsed guidance clarifies that individual events must be retained for at least five years after a change in safety software, regardless of who made the change or whether it was authorised. The record must reflect the machinery's actual safety-software status.
The guidance also addresses situations in which external devices are used to store required intervention evidence. In those arrangements, machinery must only be operational once the necessary evidence has been successfully stored.
That is a technical design consideration, not simply a document-retention task for the plant's quality department.
Another provision, Annex III section 1.2.1, second subparagraph, point (b), concerns machinery with control systems exhibiting fully or partially self-evolving behaviour or logic designed to operate with varying autonomy. Its specified safety-related decision-making data must be retained for one year after collection.
These are distinct requirements. They do not establish a general obligation to monitor every factory software intervention.
Protection against corruption is also directed towards machinery safety. The Commission's guidance considers physical and remote connections, foreseeable malicious intervention and the risk that corruption of safety-related signals, data or software could create a hazardous situation. It does not extend these requirements to protecting commercial confidentiality or intellectual property for their own sake.
EN 50742, Safety of machinery — Protection against corruption, has reached ratification in the European standardisation process. Its publication and citation of its reference in the Official Journal remain separate events. As at 15 November 2026, an Official Journal citation under the new Machinery Regulation has not been verified.
The Commission has endorsed partial application guidance on the relevant cyber-safety provisions, but comprehensive guidance on substantial modification is not among the endorsed sections.
The operational point is that a company assuming manufacturer obligations for modified machinery must be able to demonstrate compliance with the applicable essential health and safety requirements.
That can include technical capabilities and records previously regarded as matters for the machine builder or systems integrator.
Two responsibilities under one roof
The Machinery Regulation operates alongside the employer's responsibilities under Directive 2009/104/EC, as implemented nationally.
That Directive addresses the safe provision, use, maintenance and inspection of work equipment. Its requirements do not disappear because the machinery was originally supplied by an established manufacturer or modified by an external specialist.
Where a substantial modification triggers Article 18, manufacturer obligations can arise alongside those employer duties.
A production-restart authorisation establishes that the organisation has accepted the equipment for use under its operational controls. It does not automatically demonstrate completion of the manufacturer conformity-assessment process.
The original CE marking also cannot, on its own, establish conformity of a subsequent substantial modification.
This creates a management coordination challenge involving engineering, EHS, quality, procurement and plant leadership. Each function may hold part of the relevant information, while no single approval documents the statutory determination.
An established issue with a new decision point
The possibility that substantial modifications create new manufacturer responsibilities is not an entirely new concept.
Germany's Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs published its interpretation paper on substantial machinery modifications, Wesentliche Veränderung von Maschinen, in 2015, replacing an earlier paper from 2000.
Industry associations and specialist machinery-safety advisers have also addressed the subject under the previous legal framework.
The new Regulation gives substantial modification an express EU-level definition and addresses the manufacturer's obligations directly in Article 18.
For a multi-plant organisation, the challenge is to ensure that those provisions can be applied consistently across different engineering teams, integrators and national operations.
A maintenance-management system may record the work. A project-management system may document the capital approval. A commissioning file may contain the safety tests.
The unanswered question is whether those records also establish the conformity determination.
The change-register test
A management team can begin with a sample of the last 20 engineering changes involving safety-relevant machinery.
This is a TRD diagnostic rather than a legal requirement to review a fixed number of projects. Historical changes must be judged against the legislation applicable at the time, while planned projects should be assessed against the framework that will govern the modification.
For each change, the record should allow the organisation to answer:
- Timing: When was the modification made and the equipment returned to use? Which regulatory framework applied?
- Manufacturer's original plan: Was the change foreseen or planned by the original manufacturer? What evidence supports the answer?
- Safety functions: Which safety functions, required performance levels, safety integrity levels or software configurations changed? Where is the validation evidence?
- Risk: Did the modification create a new hazard or increase an existing risk? Where is that recorded?
- Protective measures: Were additional guards or protective devices required with associated safety-control-system changes, or were additional stability or strength measures necessary?
- Responsibility: Who designed, implemented and validated the work? Who carried out the modification and approved the substantial-modification determination?
- Conformity: If the modification was substantial, what affected machinery was identified, which Article 25 route applied and who took responsibility for the conformity deliverables?
- Evidence: Can the organisation retrieve the risk assessment, technical documentation, validation results and relevant software information?
A credible process should be able to explain both outcomes: why a change constituted a substantial modification and why another, technically similar project did not.
That is a more meaningful control than asking whether the work passed commissioning.
Before the next shutdown
The immediate management action is straightforward.
Examine the form used to authorise machinery changes.
Does it include a substantial-modification determination, the name of the competent reviewer, the statutory criteria applied and a reference to the supporting assessment?
Where the modification crosses the threshold, does the project identify the responsible person, affected machinery, conformity procedure and required deliverables before procurement and commissioning are completed?
The process does not require every plant director to become a machinery-law specialist. It requires the organisation to know when that specialist decision is necessary and who has the authority to make it.
A factory does not have to sell machinery to incur manufacturer obligations.
It needs to recognise when a modification it carries out meets the legal threshold.
That recognition belongs in the engineering-change approval, before the next shutdown begins.
Regulatory sources and further reading
European Union legislation
- Regulation (EU) 2023/1230, consolidated text. Recital 26; Articles 3, 10, 18, 20, 25, 52 and 54; Annexes I and III.
- Directive 2009/104/EC. Minimum safety and health requirements for the use of work equipment by workers.
European Commission guidance and standards
- Machinery Regulation: European Commission information and guidance.
- Temporary and partial Machinery Regulation application guide. Cyber-safety sections endorsed 5 November 2026.
- European Commission harmonised machinery standards register.
National interpretative reference
Regulatory position reviewed 15 November 2026. This article provides independent analysis of EU machinery legislation and operational governance. Application to an individual modification requires assessment of the actual machinery, technical circumstances, applicable requirements and relevant legal interpretation.
Legacy edition
This earlier edition is preserved in the archive. The full original publication is available externally where a verified edition link exists.
Read the full original edition on LinkedIn ↗